Skip to content
onsuggest
Log in
Article en

The idiot's reductio

Source: LessWrong ·

Subtitle: if you truly believed that... Every once in a while, I encounter what I call the idiot’s reductio : “If you truly believed X, you’d do Y. Since you don’t do Y, you must not actually believe X.” A special case is when people say “I don’t believe in/feel/have X. But if you truly did believe in X, you’d do a crazy and absurd thing. Since you don’t do this crazy and absurd thing, I conclude you don’t believe in X, and also X isn’t real.” Almost always incredibly childish and a complete failure of theory of mind. Some examples: If you actually believed in the Christian Bible, you’d avoid

What is The idiot's reductio?

The idiot's reductio is a article discovery curated from LessWrong. Subtitle: if you truly believed that... Every once in a while, I encounter what I call the idiot’s reductio : “If you truly believed X, you’d do Y. Since you don’t do Y, you must…

How can I access or experience this?

You can experience this content directly on its original host (LessWrong) by clicking the "Open Original" button.

Where does this content come from?

Curated from LessWrong by the OnSuggest team to surface the most interesting and serendipitous content on the web.

Article · Culture & ideas

“Give Me the Ball!” Serves a Powerful Portrait of Billie Jean King

Billie Jean King and Ilana Kloss attend the premiere of Give Me the Ball! by Liz Garbus and Elizabeth Wolff, an official selection of the 2026 Sundance Film Festival. (© 2026 Sundance Institute | photo by Jemal Countess) By Ramona Flume “This film you’re about to see is an extraordinary documentary about a competitor, a […] The post “Give Me the Ball!” Serves a Powerful Portrait of Billie Jean King first appeared on sundance.org .

Sundance News View Details →
Article · Culture & ideas

Former ‘Blade’ Director Left MCU Reboot Because “Life’s Too Short to Make Sh-t Films”

For years, Marvel Studios and the Marvel Cinematic Universe ignored anything that came before Iron Man, regardless of what audiences thought. This means that, despite Wesley Snipes‘ Blade helping kick start the idea of Marvel movies, the franchise not only ignored those movies, but also left the character behind entirely. Then, in 2019, Marvel Studios […] The post Former ‘Blade’ Director Left MCU Reboot Because “Life’s Too Short to Make Sh-t Films” appeared first on Bloody Disgusting! .

Bloody Disgusting View Details →
Article · Culture & ideas

‘Hellraiser: Revival’ Wins Game of the Year at The Horror Game Awards 2026

While Resident Evil Requiem took home the most awards at The Horror Game Awards this year, Clive Barker’s Hellraiser: Revival won the coveted Game of the Year Award, beating out Requiem. The Saber Interactive title also took home the Best Performance for Doug Bradley‘s return as the iconic Pinhead. Despite missing out on Game of […] The post ‘Hellraiser: Revival’ Wins Game of the Year at The Horror Game Awards 2026 appeared first on Bloody Disgusting! .

Bloody Disgusting View Details →

Keyboard shortcuts

Previous discovery
←P
Next discovery
→N
Like
L
Not for me
X
Save
S
Show this help
?
Close
Esc

Shortcuts work on the discovery page.